Paleo versus atkins

Atkins Diet or the Paleo Diet: Which one is for me?

Health and weight loss have often been linked with strict, nearly impossible eating regimens. Who hasn't heard of Gwyneth Paltrow’s stringent macrobiotic diet? Luckily for meat lovers, other diets have emerged catering to the tastes of would-be carnivores while promoting weight loss, health and overall well-being.

Atkins for Life - the bookWhat is the Atkins Diet: Delicious Weight Loss

The Atkins diet has been around for decades, often making popular appearances in popular culture. Most recently, Kim Kardashian cited Atkins as the reason for her epic weight loss after giving birth. The Atkins diet centers on depriving the body from quick energy sources to force your system to resort to stored fats for energy in a process referred to as ‘ketosis’.

The advantage the Atkins diet has over other diets is its range of desirable foods. Dieters on Atkins can enjoy butters, fats, mayonnaise, fatty meats, cheese and full fat dairy without having to feel guilty. However, there are strict carbohydrate limitations which rule out all fruits and many vegetables – both of which are healthy parts of most diets.

What to Eat on the Atkins Diet

The Atkins diet consists of four stages: induction, ongoing weight loss, pre-maintenance and maintenance. The first stage is the most restrictive, with less than 20 grams of carbohydrates allowed. The 20 grams must come from greens or low-carbohydrate vegetables such as spinach, cauliflower, asparagus and broccoli. The dieter then slowly introduces other food types, previously not allowed, following a food ladder.

atkins-diet-menu
The Atkins Diet and Life Style

Foods allowed in all stages are:

  • Fish and shellfish
  • Poultry, bacon, beef, ham, pork, venison and veal.
  • Non-starch vegetables like greens and mushrooms
  • Cheese, including blue cheese, cheddar, cream cheese, feta, Gouda, mozzarella, Parmesan and Swiss
  • Condiments and seasonings
  • Beverages, including club soda, coffee, diet soda and herbal tea free of barley or fruit sugar

Foods introduced into the diet in latter stages are:

  • Foundation vegetables
  • Nuts and seeds
  • Berries
  • Whole milk and yogurt
  • Legumes
  • Tomato juice
  • Other fruits
  • Starchy vegetables
  • Whole grains

What are the Effects of Eating a Low-Carb Diet?

Effects-of-Low-Carb-Diet

What is the Paleo Diet? (Eat Like a Caveman)

what is paleo dietPopular among many celebrities and fitness enthusiasts, the Paleo diet (short for ‘Paleolithic’) has taken center stage in the past couple of years. As you may have guessed, this diet is based on the eating habits of Paleolithic humans, more commonly referred to as ‘cavemen’. There is one ground rule in the Paleo diet: you can only eat what cavemen ate. If a certain food cannot be obtained by means of hunting and gathering, it should not be part of your diet. The second rule of Paleo is to stay as natural as possible, and avoid all kinds of processed foods, chemicals and artificial components.

The scientific theory behind this rule is that human genes have not evolved since the Paleolithic age, and hence, the human body is not equipped to deal with the foods that were introduced to our diets after this era. Scientists argue that in eating these foods we are not genetically equipped to deal with, have led to ‘maladaptations’, such as diabetes.

What to Eat on the Paleo Diet

The Paleo PyramidThe foods you can eat on a Paleo diet are:

  • Fruits
  • Vegetables
  • Meat (pasture-raised)
  • Fish and seafood
  • Nuts and seeds
  • Eggs
  • Healthy oils, such as olive oil and coconut oil

Meats should optimally be free range and grass-fed. If that’s unattainable, organic meat that has not been subjected to hormones and antibiotics is a viable alternative. It is important to stay away from fatty meat parts such as chicken skins, since that’s where most of the unnatural substances deposit. Eggs should also be free range and organic.

It is important to note that peanuts are not considered nuts, so you might have to replace peanut butter with nut butters such as almond butter.

The foods you shouldn't eat on a Paleo diet are:

  • Dairy
  • Legumes (such as beans or chickpeas)
  • Grains
  • Artificial foods and drinks such as soda and jelly
  • Vegetable oils
  • Genetically modified foods
  • Fruit juices

Paleo vs Atkins: How to Choose which Diet is best for you

Diet Advice ConfusionThe choice between Paleo and Atkins is highly personal. Both diets require a degree of commitment, but while Atkins eliminates certain foods for a limited period of time and then reintroduces them, Paleo rules out certain foods for good. You should ask yourself whether you are willing to completely rid your diet of dairy, legumes, carbohydrates, sodas and artificial products.

If your main focus is health, Paleo generally brings some advantages. Adopting a completely natural eating style and eliminating chemicals altogether should do wonders for your health. The integration of clean organic produce and healthy, grass-fed meats combined with the elimination of foods that cause metabolic problems, like dairy and grains, will promote higher energy levels and feelings of well-being.

This contrasts with the negative health impacts that some Atkins dieters see when they indulge in fatty meats and butters, causing their cholesterol levels to skyrocket. Even with a keen eye on avoiding the unhealthy side of Atkins, the diet doesn't help rid your body of chemicals. On the contrary, sodas, artificial sweeteners and artificial foods are all integrated into the Atkins diet.

Opt In Image
Get your free e-book!
99 Workouts, no equipment required

Join the "Moose is Loose" tribe and receive health, fitness and wellness tips to keep you motivated, educated and inspired... and it all starts here!

In This E-book, You'll Learn:

  • Fast and effective workouts
  • Low to moderate to high intensity options for all levels
  • Constantly varied movements to keep you from getting bored
  • No equipment required for any of the 99 workouts

Stop making excuses for not having a gym or access to equipment, get the free e-book now!

7 comments

  1. I follow a Keto diet (High Fat Low Carb) which is basically like the induction phase on Atkins. I’ve been eating this way for nearly a year and have had some great health benefits as a result. I didn’t have any weight to lose as I had lost 100 pounds a few years prior. I started it to help with PCOS. My insomnia is gone, no more sugar crashes or cravings, acne is gone and my hormonal issues have cleared up.

  2. Dude, it’s simple. Dr Atkins died. Cavemen are aliv…oh, wait, never mind.

    Still, Paleo is the way to go. It even rhymes!

    • Stupid comment. Atkins slipped on a sidewalk and hit his head and, NO, it wasn’t because he was dizzy. You ever fall on your butt in the winter?

      • I think you missed the point of my comment. I wasn’t Atkins is right. Kinda on the contrary. No one is ‘right’. I’t was a somewhat sarcastic comment, but my point is really saying that neither diet leads to the fountain of youth. The right diet is a very personal thing, and can’t protect you from everything else (as Atkins and Cavemen prove).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

e4f2082f9f3a19ab489b6b171f845ffbd079083c6187e9365a